Since its debut in the late 1960s, Naruto—two series that have defined the shonen genre and influenced generations of creators and fans.
What is the secret behind Weekly Shonen Jump’s unparalleled success? Fans and creators alike have pondered whether there’s a formula for creating timeless manga. A recently unearthed 2019 discussion between former Shonen Jump editors offers some answers, particularly on how One Piece and Naruto shaped each other’s development. Yahagi Kosuke, editor of Naruto from its manga debut until Chapter #402, shared his insights on Kishimoto’s creative process and the significant influence One Piece had on Naruto’s evolution.
"There's No Way Naruto Can Compete with One Piece"
In the Shadow of Luffy and the Straw Hat Pirates
Yahagi revealed that Kishimoto initially doubted Naruto could rival the popularity of One Piece. “Masashi Kishimoto often said, ‘There’s no way Naruto can compete with One Piece. It’s just too interesting,’” Yahagi recalled. Despite this, the team broke down One Piece’s storytelling techniques to learn from its success.
One key takeaway was One Piece’s ability to balance episodic adventures with overarching growth. Yahagi explained, “Each new arc in One Piece introduces a clear goal, concludes with the protagonist’s growth, and sets up the next adventure. This structure, paired with fresh and unique worlds in every arc, keeps the series exciting.” The story also maintains its focus on Luffy’s journey while building a strong ensemble cast.
Faced with the challenge of standing out, Kishimoto and his team decided to embrace their own strengths rather than mimic One Piece. “Kishimoto said, ‘I can’t write a story more moving than One Piece,’ so we focused on surprising readers with intense action and emotional depth,” Yahagi noted. This distinct approach allowed Naruto to carve out its own identity, emphasizing themes like perseverance and personal growth.
Which is the better power system: Haki (One Piece) or Chakra (Naruto)?
Undoubtedly, Naruto and One Piece are among the biggest anime series ever, and both actively used a power system to establish the prominence of their characters. One Piece’s Haki and Naruto’s Chakra are two of the most iconic, each offering unique mechanics. Which of the two do you think had a better power system, One Piece or Naruto?
Staying True to Your Own Vision
How Competition Can Fuel Creativity
The creative friction between One Piece and Naruto not only pushed Kishimoto to innovate but also showcased how competition can fuel creativity. Both series have left an indelible mark on manga, proving that success isn’t about following a formula but about telling a compelling story in your own voice.
Ultimately, the journey of Naruto—inspired but not overshadowed by One Piece—is a testament to the power of learning from peers while staying true to your own vision. Believe it!
Source: Reddit
Naruto is an action-adventure anime series based on the manga series created by Masashi Kishimoto. The titular Naruto Uzumaki is a fearsome Nine-Tailed Fox Spirit sealed inside him, which once wreaked havoc on his village. Shunned by his community yet determined to earn their respect, Naruto dreams of becoming the greatest ninja, the Hokage. This series follows his journey through the Ninja Academy as he continues to train and grow, hoping to prove himself to his peers- and himself.
Your comment has not been saved