No way... Benedict's Sherlock was the best modern day Sherlock Holmes adaptation... Look at The performances of Benedict and Freeman even the actor who played Mrs Hudson, you instantly believe them in their roles and you fall in love with each character like within 2 to 3 appearances.. every character of the show is so strong and well developed that you can't miss the scenes even when there are no main characters for example scenes with lestrade and Anderson... I mean can someone even compare Sherlock with Elementary there's no comparison whatsoever, Sherlock is all about 221B baker Street and in elementary roaming in new York working with NYPD ?? a character who's base is that he's a high functioning sociopath who's brains runs as fast as The Flash who's biggest addiction is deduction... In elementary I can't find Sherlock if he himself doesn't tell me that he's Sherlock.... Even RDJs Sherlock was good but this is crap they tried different worked okayish but saying it better than BBCs Sherlock is a crime